Search results

  1. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Riptide's P1P1 Thread

    I would pick Fire Covenant. Looking at your list there are a lot of creatures with power 2 or less, making it fairly cheap in terms of life cost for an instant speed, one-sided wrath. The only mark against it is that it is the only true gold card in the pack. I wonder if it might be too good for...
  2. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    The trouble with Provoke is that you can't use it reliably to kill creatures with tap abilities. They can just tap down again before the declare blockers step and become safe.
  3. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    I like the idea of pushing the power level of these cards. Cogwork Librarian is a card that I enjoy in draft, but is never going to make your deck, hence its only value is to be able to pick two cards. But what if were something not only playable but powerful? That could be a delightful tension...
  4. Humpty_Dumpty

    General CBS

    Hyperbole aside, what is your objection to the arena cube? It appears to me to just be a mess of "good cards", but that is where a lot of our cubes started and were still a lot of fun. Personally I miss the social interaction, and prefer games to be played out within pods, as it feels that...
  5. Humpty_Dumpty

    General (BLB) Bloomburrow Spoilers

    I have two thoughts about Bloomburrow. The first is the wording for gifts, which are promised not given. Maybe I’m just a duplicitous bastard, but why can’t I break my promise? The second is that it feels odd to have threshold back as a main-set mechanic after all these years. In Odyssey block...
  6. Humpty_Dumpty

    General (BLB) Bloomburrow Spoilers

    Emrakul has 14 tentacles. This means that she can defend against all but one of the squirrels, who fatally gnaws on her brain.
  7. Humpty_Dumpty

    General [Contest] 30+ Eggs in one Basket

    I would play these cubes. But not with TrainmasterGT who would just eat the cards.
  8. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets [ACR] Universes Beyond™: Assassin's Creed™ Previews

    I played the renaissance Italy one and the pirate one. Quite fun to parkour around Venice and sail around the Caribbean. I liked the jumping and climbing puzzles, but agree that the fighting was a bit tedious. The main story was quite engaging, but the framing device was silly.
  9. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets [ACR] Universes Beyond™: Assassin's Creed™ Previews

    Marionette Apprentice and Emperor of Bones?
  10. Humpty_Dumpty

    General [Contest] 30+ Eggs in one Basket

    Have none of you read the title of this thread? It's 30+ eggs in one basket. Not marvels, or vistas, or cities, or wands. Eggs. biolume egg is my ovum of choice. Scry payoff, top of the library manipulation, defender tribal, sacrifice, land recursion: so much going on. Plus it's a double...
  11. Humpty_Dumpty

    General CubeCon 2024– Vote for Highball 4K!

    I too voted for you. As a firm believer that democracy is a responsibility as well as a right, I carried out my due diligence and perused your cube description on Cube Cobra. Imagine my surprise to read that you had compared your cube to the Talyllyn Railway in Gwynedd, my favourite narrow...
  12. Humpty_Dumpty

    General [Contest] Ravnica Reimagined (Entry Closed - Judging Complete!)

    Thank you for taking the time to run this competition, Onderzeeboot, and well done to all the participants. I agree that empowered is a worthy winner, and am surprised to find that it exists on only two cards. Although Gruul colours are represented by these examples, it is white that is the...
  13. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (MH3) Modern Horizons 3 Previews

    Mrs Dumpty asked me why I started laughing. I tried to explain but she is not a magic player, so now she thinks I am even sillier than usual.
  14. Humpty_Dumpty

    Card/Deck Single Card Spotlight

    Why stick to creatures? cloudstone CurioTatyova, Benthic Druidfastbond gives infinite mana and card draw. This sort of nonsense probably needs a cube like Caleb Ganon's Powered Synergy Cube.
  15. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    GU could be Mutant. The type is found in all colours of ONS creature, but I tend to think of mutants as Simic. GW could be cats? There isn’t much creature type overlap in ONS between G and W. Druids sometimes occur in white, but not in ONS. What about taking a race/class approach?
  16. Humpty_Dumpty

    General CBS

    I was trying to find my Revised dual lands but it turns out they’ve all got kids and mortgages.
  17. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (OTJ/BIG/OTC/OTP) Outlaws of Thunder Junction & The Big Score Mega Testing and Includes Thread!

    Your enthusiasm for Saddle is palpable, but none of the Mount creatures are a good fit for my cube. When they finally print the type line Creature — Dragon Mount… that I will find hard to resist.
  18. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Remix Draft: Artifacts on Arena

    Thanks for the heads up. It looks interesting and I may give it a try. Is the ‘stale’ worry that there are only 290 cards, that it is artifact focused to the exclusion of other themes, or something else? Also, if you were to do something like this, how would it differ from Cube? Would you...
  19. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (OTJ) Outlaws of Thunder Junction Previews

    Funny how this discussion of blocks comes up during spoiler season for OTJ, which I still read as Odyssey-Judgment-Torment. I feel there is a tension between story and gameplay when comparing the old block structure with modern single set approch. The former should lend itself to classic three...
  20. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    The demon and angel demonstrate some of the common problems with AI art. At first glance they look pretty cool, but closer inspection reveals a plethora of problems. The demon’s wings seem oddly small; one hand has four digits, the other has six. The angel has only one leg, a strange shaped...
Top