Search results

You’re trolling Train. Please stop. It hurts my eyes. Every sentence you said is wrong hence I have to believe you’re just arguing to argue. This I do not like. There is nothing I do not understand, please. I did prove it several times. And Wizards know it too. If we don’t voice our concern...

Thank you for praising me and saying I have guts. It is easy to have guts when you know you are 100 % objectively right :P No one has completed the trial of answering the questions so therefore the statement still stands. Wizards didn’t evolve. They devolved. And they know it deep down but they...

You’ve located my only issue and I think you’ve located the perfect solution as well. Except maybe not as full art. I like the extensions to the left and right but not the fading of the type line.

Wasn’t an enchantment :P I’m sticking to my point of view haha :P Buh seriously Future Sight was sort of a testing set. They did all sorts of crazy things that were mostly underpowered to see how people would react. Lucent Liminid is a great example of how much they need a creature to look...

The following is not written with a snappy mind. I am just doing it briefly but I care about the discussion <3 When I said ability initially I actually meant ability. Static, activated or triggered ability. Being a creature is not an ability. I hope this makes sense as to what we are...

One card = hundreds of living beings at least Except when they’re legendary. This is what legendary means in Magic. Unique, one of a kind. When a card is not legendary they don’t assume gender because many different genders exist for each card. Acrolith has the ability to become a creature...

Yes it could if Wizards made a design error. But they haven’t made one without an ability. Why would anyone cast a spell that doesn’t do anything? The Eidolon is a creature. Dress Down has an ability. Delusions has an ability. Underworld has an ability. What we need to find is an enchantment...

Yeah all we want is for them to either do: 1. Make sure the enchantment creatures are also enchantments and not just creatures. Give them some card text and not just power/toughness. 2. Make sure they truly feel like enchantments flavor wise/lore wise. If they really stand out, sure. Fine. Then...

No An enchantment could not just have "When this enchantment enters the battlefield, draw a card." and nothing else. Because then the card would not exist. Can you show me just one enchantment with this card text and nothing else?

Addendum I can see my choice of words should maybe have been different. Maybe I should have used "flaw" instead of "mistake" Design flaw Because mistake implies that they didn't know and thought they did a good job.

For all those reasons, this is why it is a design mistake. They can justify it however they like but they are still mistakes. A better question would be to ask: "Why can artifact creatures be artifacts simply because of flavor?" There is no good answer. Because it's a design flaw. If one...

I like the extra art. It's just more than we had a few years ago. By now I have quite a big % of my cube that has an extended art so each of them no longer looks out of place. The only time I do not get the extended art (on Kaldheim or later when they fixed the extended art frame) is when it...

You could build an entire format around Vivien’s Arkbow I call it The Ark. Or Ark Cubing. Each player begins with one on the battlefield. They never draw cards from their library. Each turn they take one Basic land from the Basic Land Box. Library is full of creatures. Vivien’s Arkbow

This is normally me. But here I actually don't understand your point of view. Do you think you could elaborate on why you don't like the the extended art? I personally like that we get more art on some of the Magic cards than we did before Kaldheim.

@shamizy is right. You want your control players to feel controlly and aggro to feel aggressive. Diversity. It can’t all be a bland experience. Signposts are important. And the dog is even a design mistake because nothing enchantment about it. They just gave it that card type to fit into Neon...

I like the ability

That’s the funniest thing I have read this year looooooooool so cruel

Story or card?

I have a few cards in my cube where we have altered the mana cost. Sometimes Wizards print a card we like but we want to change the cost. Here are some examples: Ashiok's Erasure Helm of the Host Golden Guardian Nyx Lotus Oko, Thief of Crowns We use stickers There are about 15 cards...

We have two trailers for Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty - One normal one in the style we've seen over the past few years - And one anime I've added them both here: https://riptidelab.com/forum/threads/mtg-lore.3207/post-111982