Day: 016
Set:
Alara Reborn (ARB)
Release Date: April 30, 2009
Cards: 145
Leads: Aaron Forsythe (Design), Matt Place (Development)
All New Cards, Sorted by ELO:
CubeCobra Link
As a note, I will be traveling the next few days, so I will
not be making "almost daily" updates here. Saved by the title change!
Like with Legions before it, Alara Reborn is a gimmick set -- all gold. This is not the natural conclusion of "restrictions breed creativity", it's an exercise of novelty, a self-imposed challenge that led to some interesting thoughts and considerations, but slightly less so in design. It feels self-indulgent and does not deliver, and the mechanics to make the most of the all-gold set/solutions to the problems it causes feel like half-measures at best. The learnings were key, however, as subsequent tri-color sets were much better play-wise, particularly Tarkir and Tarkir 2.0.
I took my first and only Magic break during this block and the first two sets of Zendikar. While I had excitedly followed spoilers for
Shards, I became a little disillusioned by the time ARB came around. Big life changes took away my opportunities to play, and I didn't pursue new opportunities because I was pretty uninterested in what was going on in the new sets.
I like Cascade as a mechanic! It's extremely hard to cost appropriately, and many players incorrectly feel like it's "all RNG", but that's not quite the case. If you do it right, as is the case with
Bloodbraid Elf, you get the thrill of spinning the wheel but it's no more "left to chance" than a top deck. Cascade was also nice to have some counterplay to counter spells at a time they were at the peak of their power.
This is one of the few sets where I don't run any cards at all.
Bloodbraid Challenger is the closest, I guess! I've always found
Qasali Pridemage to be overrated as a Cube card, and feel I forced it in my Cube for many years because the online community saw it as an ideal GW card for all power levels. I feel like I missed out on years of experimenting with cards that could pull people into GW or inspire new archetypes like
Captain Sisay or
Tolsimir Wolfblood for a medium, hard-to-cast-on-curve pure support card. It's just not the kind of card I like to prioritize a gold slot for, especially now that we have a wealth of choices.
I like
Putrid Leech I guess. But I'll give my top slot to Bloodbraid.
