General Guess the Card

Damn, I was sure that'd be it.
300px-There_Is_Another.jpg
 
here's an easy one, but a fun memory:
casting this instant in response to villain's Lightning Bolt cost a player a large tournament finals match.
 
casting this instant in response to villain's Lightning Bolt cost a player a large tournament finals match.
I'm not familiar with the story, how did that happen? Was it something like "I was at 4 life, opp tried to Bolt me, I cast REDACTED in response, opp Boros Charmed me?"
 
I'm not familiar with the story, how did that happen? Was it something like "I was at 4 life, opp tried to Bolt me, I cast REDACTED in response, opp Boros Charmed me?"
its been a while i think but...
Player 1 cast first bolt to face, allowed it to resolve and priority to be passed back.
Player 1 cast second bolt to face, allowed it to resolve and priority to be passed back.
Player 1 cast third bolt to face for lethal...
Player 2 casts _____ in response.
Player 1 cast and resolved FOURTH LIGHTNING BOLT TO FACE FOR LETHAL
Answer to the riddle plus any corrections to my half-remembered retelling is in the link below:
 
Top