For a while now I've been enamored with the profoundly unwieldy idea of designing a cube that behaves like a legacy board game (a game that permanently changes between each play session). Many cubes toy with the idea of changing cards in and out of the list, altering abilities by writing on the cards, and so on. My goal, however – inspired by some of my favorite games such as Oath, Arcs: The Blighted Reach, or Frosthaven – is to design a flavor-first, campaign-like, experience, in which the cards in the list are treated as representations of a coherent setting (much like a regular set) and the players' decisions as historical events in it, gradually taking place over a long period of time.
The list starts out as a fairly standard, simple, draft experience, each of the colors representing a faction and its inner conflicts and secrets. Each session, players draft a deck and play a single multiplayer match. The winner of the draft chooses from a number of available card packages, and removes cards of their choice from the list and adds the cards from the package.
This means that the list might gradually become unbalanced or that the winner might punish a particular color. That's fine. If the Black Zombie Clerics are winning too much and all the other factions are getting cornered, then the Red Goblin Tribes, the White Knights, and the Green Druids can form an alliance to make sure the Zombie Clerics will lose cards – this means the cube is working as intended. If a color disappears or the cube becomes unplayable due to poor choices, that's fine too – the story of the cube is the history of its setting and the players' influence and decisions in it. The goal is not perfect mechanical and design balance, but long term role-playing and emotional investment and emergent gameplay interactions.
Due to the sheer complexity of such a thing, I'm treating it more as a thought experiment on the limits on the Magic game engine than anything else and a fun intersection between different game design-related interests. I'm using this thread as a blog, but I'd love to hear ideas and suggestions as I go along.
The basic list lives here (only for future reference, under construction, doesn't include packages...).
I've given a lot of thought to this, but I'll start with the basics and detail the rest in following posts.
Blue, for example, has the Wizard College as its major faction, with Azami, Lady of Scrolls and Gadwick, the Wizened pushing you towards a single color and a single creature type. Cards like Hapless Researcher, Erudite Wizard, or Archmage's Charm also represent this aspect of the color, either mechanically or visually. However, below the college, lies the deep ocean with its own denizens and perils. Finally, a single Merrow Harbinger, the only merfolk in the initial list, starts as mere, sad, curve-filler, yet suggests that a new order might be arriving soon.
The fate of the color depends on what the players do with it which, from my experience playing these types of games, will depend as much on mechanical pursuit (getting better cards) as on personal/thematic preference. As different packages become available over multiple sessions, a blue player might choose to make the wizards stronger, to bring back the merfolk, or to flood everything in sea critters.
1) the cube represents the world and the lands are its places. What secrets hide in the Crystal Grotto, what mysteries in the Seafloor Debris?, and so on;
2) Fighting over land fits the faction-oriented theme of draft and the setting. If you pick Tarnished Citadel and play a goblin deck, that means the goblins live there; if in the next draft the merfolk deck has Tarnished Citadel, that means they took it over from the goblins – or however you choose to interpret it;
3) The gradual imbalance of lands leaving/entering the list has a very strong connection between flavor and mechanics: a terrible flood happens and replaces basic lands with islands, Dormant Volcano erupts and a single Island is replaced with a Volcanic Island, etc.
Unlocked Packages are always open, and the winner of the draft can choose to take cards from them at the end of the game, starting from the first game, as long as the package's conditions are met. If you win the game and most of the cards in your deck are blue, for instance, you can take cards from the "Deep Sea Denizens" package. If you control five wizards at the same time, you can take cards from the "New Faculty" package instead.
Locked Packages start the game unavailable, and must be unlocked over sessions. This can happen in a variety of ways. Some packages are organized into narrative flowcharts, requiring unlocking other scenarios before. And some packages might require you to achieve something during a session (or over a series of drafts) in order to be unlocked.
Example: The Volcanic Eruption package. If you draft the Dormant Volcano, you take also its Progression Tracker. In it, you mark how many times Dormant Volcano has been played. After the fifth time, at the end of the draft, you unlock the Volcanic Eruption package and must follow its instructions. These include things such as switching random cards out with Pyroclasm, Lavalanche, Seething Song, or more specific changes, such as switching a random basic land with an Ash Barrens.
View attachment 11603
Packages can be designed as complicated as you want, and you can tell whatever story you want with them. The Industrial Revolution story might develop over a series of interconnected packages, with cards like Smokestack, Orcish Lumberjack, or Fabricate eventually opening the doors to Polluted Delta, Contaminated Ground, or Contaminated Aquifer entering the list. Maybe one package requires you to make a choice between branching paths, solve a riddle, or take cards at random. Maybe it replaces all basic lands with snow lands or gives everyone a starting Treasure Token. Maybe it requires a number of games (in world calendar) to pass. And so on.
---
This post is getting too long as is, and I'm sure I've made it much more confusing than it needed to be. I'll develop my thoughts on packages, colors, gameplay in following posts.
The list starts out as a fairly standard, simple, draft experience, each of the colors representing a faction and its inner conflicts and secrets. Each session, players draft a deck and play a single multiplayer match. The winner of the draft chooses from a number of available card packages, and removes cards of their choice from the list and adds the cards from the package.
This means that the list might gradually become unbalanced or that the winner might punish a particular color. That's fine. If the Black Zombie Clerics are winning too much and all the other factions are getting cornered, then the Red Goblin Tribes, the White Knights, and the Green Druids can form an alliance to make sure the Zombie Clerics will lose cards – this means the cube is working as intended. If a color disappears or the cube becomes unplayable due to poor choices, that's fine too – the story of the cube is the history of its setting and the players' influence and decisions in it. The goal is not perfect mechanical and design balance, but long term role-playing and emotional investment and emergent gameplay interactions.
Due to the sheer complexity of such a thing, I'm treating it more as a thought experiment on the limits on the Magic game engine than anything else and a fun intersection between different game design-related interests. I'm using this thread as a blog, but I'd love to hear ideas and suggestions as I go along.
The basic list lives here (only for future reference, under construction, doesn't include packages...).
I've given a lot of thought to this, but I'll start with the basics and detail the rest in following posts.
The Chronicle
As in Oath, you're encouraged to take a roleplaying-first approach to gameplay. This does not mean playing suboptimally, but interpreting the flow and outcome of the match narratively – why did things happen the way they did in terms of the fiction? The winner of the draft, besides choosing which cards get in and out of the list, also gets to write the Chronicle of the current era, in which they provide a short in-character account of the events that just transpired. Historiographic narrative control is its own reward, and if you've never played a game like this, you might be surprised at the level of mechanical self-sabotage in the name of flavor players are capable of – perhaps you allow someone else to win in exchange for a promise that your goblins will not be cut from the list. (see Wehrle on kingmaking)Factions
The five colors begin as clearly established factions, pushing the player to draft monocolored decks (or allied colors, at most). Each color presents a dominant theme/group, a minor theme/group, and some clearly isolated 'off' cards that point towards future possibilities. Thematically, each faction should feel decadent and slightly oppressive, reactive and tired powers in an old world of fragile alliances. Individual cards tell the story of the world and its denizens, emphasizing visual impact and aesthetic coherence – i.e. there are 'art cards' (cards which are in the cube purely for aesthetic reasons).Blue, for example, has the Wizard College as its major faction, with Azami, Lady of Scrolls and Gadwick, the Wizened pushing you towards a single color and a single creature type. Cards like Hapless Researcher, Erudite Wizard, or Archmage's Charm also represent this aspect of the color, either mechanically or visually. However, below the college, lies the deep ocean with its own denizens and perils. Finally, a single Merrow Harbinger, the only merfolk in the initial list, starts as mere, sad, curve-filler, yet suggests that a new order might be arriving soon.
The fate of the color depends on what the players do with it which, from my experience playing these types of games, will depend as much on mechanical pursuit (getting better cards) as on personal/thematic preference. As different packages become available over multiple sessions, a blue player might choose to make the wizards stronger, to bring back the merfolk, or to flood everything in sea critters.
A Desert Cube
I decided to make it a desert cube for a few reasons:1) the cube represents the world and the lands are its places. What secrets hide in the Crystal Grotto, what mysteries in the Seafloor Debris?, and so on;
2) Fighting over land fits the faction-oriented theme of draft and the setting. If you pick Tarnished Citadel and play a goblin deck, that means the goblins live there; if in the next draft the merfolk deck has Tarnished Citadel, that means they took it over from the goblins – or however you choose to interpret it;
3) The gradual imbalance of lands leaving/entering the list has a very strong connection between flavor and mechanics: a terrible flood happens and replaces basic lands with islands, Dormant Volcano erupts and a single Island is replaced with a Volcanic Island, etc.
Packages
Packages come in two categories: locked and unlocked.Unlocked Packages are always open, and the winner of the draft can choose to take cards from them at the end of the game, starting from the first game, as long as the package's conditions are met. If you win the game and most of the cards in your deck are blue, for instance, you can take cards from the "Deep Sea Denizens" package. If you control five wizards at the same time, you can take cards from the "New Faculty" package instead.
Locked Packages start the game unavailable, and must be unlocked over sessions. This can happen in a variety of ways. Some packages are organized into narrative flowcharts, requiring unlocking other scenarios before. And some packages might require you to achieve something during a session (or over a series of drafts) in order to be unlocked.
Example: The Volcanic Eruption package. If you draft the Dormant Volcano, you take also its Progression Tracker. In it, you mark how many times Dormant Volcano has been played. After the fifth time, at the end of the draft, you unlock the Volcanic Eruption package and must follow its instructions. These include things such as switching random cards out with Pyroclasm, Lavalanche, Seething Song, or more specific changes, such as switching a random basic land with an Ash Barrens.
View attachment 11603
Packages can be designed as complicated as you want, and you can tell whatever story you want with them. The Industrial Revolution story might develop over a series of interconnected packages, with cards like Smokestack, Orcish Lumberjack, or Fabricate eventually opening the doors to Polluted Delta, Contaminated Ground, or Contaminated Aquifer entering the list. Maybe one package requires you to make a choice between branching paths, solve a riddle, or take cards at random. Maybe it replaces all basic lands with snow lands or gives everyone a starting Treasure Token. Maybe it requires a number of games (in world calendar) to pass. And so on.
---
This post is getting too long as is, and I'm sure I've made it much more confusing than it needed to be. I'll develop my thoughts on packages, colors, gameplay in following posts.