Search results

  1. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    If you are curating the pool of commanders that can be combined, you can set you own level of insanity. Certainly you might miss an egregious combination, but learn from it and decide whether to swap out one of the offending pair. I’d be tempted to go further, and give my two-coloured legends...
  2. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Fight Club

    I’m going to remove big Saheeli and keep both of the above cards. Thanks everyone for your help.
  3. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Fight Club

    Saheeli, Sublime ArtificerThird Path Iconoclast Both produce 1/1 artifact tokens. Saheeli costs more, but has the more flexible mana cost. Iconoclast beats down, Saheeli has a somewhat useful ability. Which is better?
  4. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (LTR) The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth

    What are the chances are that The One Ring is opened by a casual player who has no idea as to its value? Or is sat indefinitely in an unopened booster box? Conversely, if someone goes on social media within the first few days of the set being released to show off the One Ring, will that tank...
  5. Humpty_Dumpty

    General New Format: Oathbreaker

    My teenage son and his schoolmates played oathbreaker for a bit, but it swiftly devolved into repetitive brokenness and they reverted to Commander. If only to placate ravnic, I wonder if there would be any value in having an oathbreaker cube, similar to how some people have designed commander...
  6. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (LTR) The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth

    “The Ring was trying to get back to its master. It had slipped from Isildur's hand and betrayed him; then when a chance came it caught poor Déagol, and he was murdered; and after that Gollum, and it had devoured him. It could make no further use of him: he was too small and mean; and as long as...
  7. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Fight Club

    viashino sandstalker This was good enough to be in a World Championship Deck. In 1998.
  8. Humpty_Dumpty

    General CBS

    Make poison a viable strategy in your cube and the villain’s life gain won’t matter.
  9. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (MoM) April of the Machines Previews

    Wasn’t Venser already Doctor Who?
  10. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (MoM) April of the Machines Previews

    Thanks for providing the link, but my previous attempts to engage with the MtG story have been frustrating: I’d rather spend my time reading better written books. I find that I can pick up enough from the cards to have a vague idea of what is going on. Although my story may differ in some of...
  11. Humpty_Dumpty

    General [Lucky Paper] The History of the Cube Format

    Lovely article. This article by Sam Gomersall was the one that prompted me to build my first cube back in 2005, and more importantly is the article Evan Erwin referenced in his article the following year that really blew the lid off cube drafting. Sam was a really nice guy and the best player...
  12. Humpty_Dumpty

    Card/Deck Low Power Card Spotlight

    Ship-eating troll sounds like an obnoxious participant on an internet fan forum.
  13. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Custom Cards: The Lab

    I would be tempted to delve deeper into the Dominaria United design approach, where each colour focuses on a particular theme and the colour pairs relate to the intersection of those themes. For example white was about having lots of creatures, red was about having big creatures, and Baird...
  14. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (ONE) Phyrexia: All Will Be One Previews

    You can’t reference ability words mechanically in the same way you can keywords. MaRo confirmed this in an article last year: I don’t know why you can’t reference an ability word, but there you go. I agree that it is odd that Channel is not a keyword, but it may be a good thing that it isn’t. I...
  15. Humpty_Dumpty

    Sets (ONE) Phyrexia: All Will Be One Previews

    That point on the path was here.
  16. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Why Slash Panther is no longer a Vintage Staple

    I was amoosed by this.
  17. Humpty_Dumpty

    General Alternative Design Methods

    This makes perfect sense. If you’re starting with Storm Crow you clearly don’t give a toss about the colour.
  18. Humpty_Dumpty

    General (BRO) The Brother's War Testing/Includes Thread

    I agree with the comments above, and would add that in BRO limited the card also benefits from artifact and soldier synergies, without which it further loses value.
  19. Humpty_Dumpty

    Card/Deck Single Card Spotlight

    I try not to think about Humility because I would need to understand layers and time stamps and quantum entanglement and those things make my brain hurt. Plus it shuts off ETB effects. Magus of the Tabernacle randomly hoses go-wide decks, which I try to support in my cube, so I wouldn’t run...
Top