Yeah, but look at the cards which were in the GrimJar deck.
Grim monolith
Mana vault
Voltaic key
Dark ritual
Lotus petal
Mox diamond
Memory jar
Megrim
I think the fast mana was the culprit. One tournament sealed the fate of the wrong card and it got retroactively added to the previous ban list...
We haven't seen it written before like this is a fallacy. We haven't seen cleave before...
Write it such that it is clear to the reader. We all live and learn. How it is written in the past does not matter.
The original (kicker) one is great!
Less mechanics/keywords is often better!
Welcome to wotc money grab bomb cards...
In their goal to have no negatives for one player (the caster) they actually made the game less fun due to the times you could not do anything against a card...
Even a very bomby card like worship has more counterplay since it does not present a clock...
If they do not kill it, they die by the judge. It has vigilance and flying so in most cases it demands an answer.
I like it a lot. Sweet mini game and it breaks open board stalls in an original way. It is fair since you have 3 turns before it starts attacking and when you have to kill it you...
This is a strong card!
I remember reading an article of mr Rosewater on oddesey block and somewhere in there stood that threshold was not a great mechanic, since it requires keeping track of something you are not used to... Seems they made an 180 on that assessment.
I like them too. A word of warning, the apprentices of the invasion set made combat calculations very hard. To many of these choice cards will complicate the board tremendously.
Funny that you mention clean and elegant. Cleave is neither, split or kicker for these cards would be (at least for me). It is mentally taxing since I have to read it first with the brackets which is a bit hard to grok and then read it while removing the brackets which is again a bit hard.
Hmm, cheap is relative of course but I do not find (eternal/paper) competitive magic cheap. It is very much pay to be able to compete and often the more expensive decks are better (burn is a great counterexample)
That was also my defense. Still, no bueno. As stated above you can use to the power minus one instead of division. Ah well, I still graduated so all worked out.
Well, it was a math study. And although it was a bit pedantic, it was stated in the book of the course. Serves me right by making the exam without reading the book, eh. It could help some people with remembering the 0 case (division by x, x unkown).