I was planning to at least announce the winner and my thoughts. Not sure about critiques of all the other entries yet though. Is that something people would be interested in?
Article CubeTutor Champion Contest
- Thread starter James Stevenson
- Start date
Chris Taylor
Contributor
Deffs yes!
I mean that's a lot of writing, so I'd totally be down for it to be a 2 parter, but why certain entries didn't get picked can be more enlightening than why the winner won
I mean that's a lot of writing, so I'd totally be down for it to be a 2 parter, but why certain entries didn't get picked can be more enlightening than why the winner won
Grillo_Parlante
Contributor
er...I already started toying with the list I submited because its 352 rather than 360, but you can have at it I suppose.
I would rather have a discussion of the lists rather than critiques. I have a few opinions I would like to solicite to make the cube better, and there is a lot of potentially good discussion ground to cover (e.g. blacksmith's squadron cube idea).
I would rather have a discussion of the lists rather than critiques. I have a few opinions I would like to solicite to make the cube better, and there is a lot of potentially good discussion ground to cover (e.g. blacksmith's squadron cube idea).
Eheheheheh I'm not looking forward to an honest review of the squad cube but by all means go ahead, it's not like I have to read it or anything
Eheheheheh I'm not looking forward to an honest review of the squad cube but by all means go ahead, it's not like I have to read it or anything
Aoret
Developer
Yes, but if I were you I think I'd kill myself before having to write that much. If you're willing to fall on the sword though... by all means review them!
also, @Grillo, yeah as soon as I hit "send" last night I remembered a bunch of swaps that I'd left out of my submission D: I knew I would too... I sat there rereading it over and over like "I'm sure I'm forgetting like seven ideas I had at lunch..."
How about discussing your top 3 entries instead of all of them, so you're not stuck writing a novel?
Chris Taylor
Contributor
I was just going for comments on them. You know, stuff you like, stuff you didn't like, etc.
I think if we want card by card analysis of the whole thing we'd post the list ourselves
I think if we want card by card analysis of the whole thing we'd post the list ourselves
My personal preference as to what I would like to see to tie the competition to an end.
I want to personally see how much %age of cards overlap between cubes to acclimatise to Mr. Waddells tastes.
- List of all submitted cubetutor links along with entrants name
- Winner with blurb on why it won
I want to personally see how much %age of cards overlap between cubes to acclimatise to Mr. Waddells tastes.
Chris Taylor
Contributor
I for one look forward to seeing some of the more masturbatory entries
You can find perhaps the most auto-erotic entry in my sig, good Vengevine
Show of hands, who has sigs on?
Chris Taylor
Contributor
It's probably the best way to actually answer those questions about random peoples cubes
Like "Maybe this post makes a lot more sense if this person usually drafts a cube chok full of combo"
That's a really good point.It's probably the best way to actually answer those questions about random peoples cubes
Somewhere around half a dozen. About the same as the last contest.