General Custom Cards: The Lab

Onderzeeboot

Ecstatic Orb
Sorry for assigning you with a large task for a small reward:

I have run this draft ability in my cube for many years. Here is a link:

http://www.cubetutor.com/visualspoiler/97699

If you scroll 99,5 % of the way to the bottom you find the card right above the 10 Signets. I believe I have shared the card on this forum before. I am at work and cannot take a picture for you.

I am at home and can take a picture for you ;) Boss art by the way.

Signet Wish.png

As far as reminder text goes, you still need to know what a Signet does, which is kinda not what Chris was looking for.

Maybe... "Trade this for a Signet of your choice. (Each Signet costs {2} and has: "{1}, {T}: Add two specific colors.")

By the way, Awe for the Guilds uses pretty art for a card that nobody remembers. Great art to steal ;)

d6x8fb6-52b2b85d-9783-4947-bcdc-2cdcc43d934a.jpg

https://www.deviantart.com/guterrez/art/Awe-for-the-Guilds-418617474
Illustrated by Mathias Kollros
 
I agree that you certainly could provide the players with 100 % of the card text. I do this with Scrolls because they are custom cards based on real cards but I do not do it with the Choose cards like Temples, Bounce lands and Signet because people already know what they do. The text is a lawyer text. There are no other cards that corrosponds to the draft ability text. Experienced players cannot have doubt. Newbies can.

I never use Magic art for custom cards.

Those were my advices :) Feel free to do whatever you want :D
 
You could have the signet choice be a hierarchy rather than a roll-off. ie Signet Choice 1 is going to be a higher pick than Signet Choice 4, and you don't get the scenario of randomly missing out on the signet you wanted because of losing a roll, whereas if you pick a low signet choice card you know that's a risk.
 

Chris Taylor

Contributor
I agree that you certainly could provide the players with 100 % of the card text. I do this with Scrolls because they are custom cards based on real cards but I do not do it with the Choose cards like Temples, Bounce lands and Signet because people already know what they do. The text is a lawyer text. There are no other cards that corrosponds to the draft ability text. Experienced players cannot have doubt. Newbies can.

I never use Magic art for custom cards.

Those were my advices :) Feel free to do whatever you want :D

I try not too, but if you've got non-magic art that includes all 10 guild symbols, please let me know :p
This came to me at 3am. Not the most polished idea
 
I have 10 foil Signets that are real Magic cards. As per the link :)

The custom card is only the enabler.

By the way I have been thinking about cutting Choose a Signet from my cube and thus cutting Signet.
 

Chris Taylor

Contributor
Even if it's "wrong" I'm gonna try it for a while. It's been years since ramp was even a thing in my cube at all, so it's not like there's suddenly rampant growth sitting on the sidelines
 
I'm looking for graveyard hate that I didn't find through my Gatherer search for "exile."



Couple that I knew of already.

Maybe there's a card that already does this, but I couldn't find it so here it is:
Inspiration is Burning Earth and Burning Vengeance

Earth's Burning Vengeance
2R - Enchantment
Whenever a player casts a spell from their graveyard, ~ deals 2 damage to that player.
Whenever one or more cards would be put into a player's hand or library from their graveyard, ~ deals 2 damage to that player.
 

Onderzeeboot

Ecstatic Orb
Maybe there's a card that already does this, but I couldn't find it so here it is:
Inspiration is Burning Earth and Burning Vengeance

Earth's Burning Vengeance
2R - Enchantment
Whenever a player casts a spell from their graveyard, ~ deals 2 damage to that player.
Whenever one or more cards would be put into a player's hand or library from their graveyard, ~ deals 2 damage to that player.
This spell specifically does not punish Crucible of Worlds effects, nor Zombify type of cards. If you don't want that, you could change the wording to a much simpler...

Whenever a card leaves a player's graveyard, unless it's exiled, ~ deals 2 damage to that player.
 
I came across a very interesting card on reddit earlier today.

kgzy8oalmx331.jpg


I think this compares effectively to Thoughtseize without being as bad for games and fun as other t1 blind discard spells. One of the biggest problems with targeted discard for B is that it creates this asymmetrical early game where the player with the discard (Villain) can curve out or play their one early threat and then Hero is stuck getting time walked on threats and is brutishly out-tempo'd. Giving Hero a Treasure to play their 3 drop on turn 2 with removes the asymmetrical development issue, and the ramp from the treasure incentives forcing a discard of a more expensive card than might otherwise be warranted - how often do you really Thoughtseize a 5-drop?

I think this would be really cool as a t1 targeted discard spell at a variety of power levels, while playing a Thoughtseize / Duress-like role and producing fewer non-games at the same time. I haven't tested this myself, or even printed the multiple proxies I'll likely run, but I think this is the best designed targeted discard spell I've ever seen, and I simply had to share it.
 

Onderzeeboot

Ecstatic Orb
I'm not going to run 1 cmc targeted discard anymore, but this is a beautifully designed card all the way, from the excellent mechanics of the card to the brilliant name. Top notch!
 
Clap, clap, clap..
(Clapping sound continues for a few minutes)

What a gem!

I usually don't run such sweet utility cards as custom cards in my cube because I want my customs to be supporting build-around cards (Like the colorless Demonic Pact a few pages back.) that can help bring consistency to a strategies that is missing some support.

I am going to break my rule/guideline for Penny for Your Thoughts.

Can we find a better name? It is not very Magicy to use Earthly currencies such as Pennies.

I don't use Reddit because it seems like I can never find anything worth my time in there. No discussions that make sense. This card might just change my mind :p Maybe I have been looking the wrong places. Can someone tell me where I find a good place on Reddit? Maybe the place where Safra found Penny for Your Thoughts?
 

Onderzeeboot

Ecstatic Orb
Can we find a better name?

The Reddit post is titled "Thought$eize", though that is hardly better if you're worrying about Earthly currencies :D

In all honesty, part of the excellent flavor is in the name, I wouldn't change it, unless you could translate it to something equally resonant.
 

Chris Taylor

Contributor
Alright I'm home I'm drunk lets talk design!
Saias Price.png
This is the best kind of custom card: "There's no way this is a custom card, WotC has totally done this right? Right?"

Wheat from Chaff.png
I might actually just add this to my cube. Nice balancing on the numbers all around.

Control Discourse.png
Similarly cool. Also this basically can't be broken, since it scales with a mechanic that's inherently hard to use. Paying someone off for their already broken cards is one thing, but paying someone off in a "just squeak past the bar" way as a mana leak with a mechanic that has a tapering power curve? I like this set.

Dying Breath.png
Again, same deal. At it's most broken, this kills a creature. Great ceiling for a scaling effect. Having a million clues isn't actually a problem.

Lost Memories.png
Okay here's something more interesting. 1 color commands that just feel natural? Maybe I'm just way into investigate, but I feel like all 3 modes of this will see their choices based on board state and deck construction. Even if it's probably an uncommon, I'm in. Love it!

Wistful Automaton.png
Okay, transform cards are hard to do. Mechanically, I'm not even sure this one really clicks for me.
But oh damn. I love the concept, I love the art, I love the themes this works into (It's an artifact, you can proliferate it, and it has prowess. That's basically everything my cube has ever done in a single card!)
Plus did I mention the awesome take on transform cards this set has? Actor is an in universe creature type, and some actors transform as the plot demands! The Comedy/Tragedy masks feel totally at home in place of the Night/Day marks from actual magic, and transform cards have always been made to tell a story; why not literalize that in the card?

Look, maybe this card means something more to people, there's this whole throughline of putting in a lot of work doing something you hate and then finally feeling whole, but even without that I'm so on board. Can't praise it enough :D

Canopy Scout.png
A lot of us might be re-examining Loam with the printing of Modern Horizons 1 (I certainly am), and maybe a 2 drop isn't what I need, and this 2 drop is probably far from the end product, but there's something there.
I'll feel it out and report back.

Performer of Growth.png
Okay, here's the piece de resistance. This is the reason I geek out about this set with my co-workers.
This set is called Villains: The Musical. There's a ton of musical inspired stuff (Actors, curtains, costumes, acts, etc) but there's also Villains. And like any good villian, they have an arc.

So, pop quiz, for which I don't really know the answer: Who's the last green villain?

Who's the last green villian who's plan is green, and who's card is not only a slam dunk, but also involves land tokens?
Seriously, this is druid of the cowl, and when you do cool green things, you get a giant creature who both ramps you and gets bigger each turn. (Yeah works if your opponents don't play a land too!)
AND ITS A SQUIRREL! Maybe it's the alcohol talking, but I didn't think there was a convincing reason to bring squirrels back to magic, and now I'm kinda on the fence.
That's gotta be worth something.

I suppose I should make it known at this point that I made this list while sober, but the writing is while drunk, so this card impressed me even when I wasn't 3 sheets to the wind.

Kiku the Gadgeteer.png
That second line of text is pure genius. I hate commander, but I still wanna go scryfall diving trying to find the most broken thing I can do with it :D

Ruined Theater.png
It's a true testament to the theater/transform parallels that this works as well as it does.
Plus I wish this was in every set where Unknown Shores was. I know thats not remotely feasable, but in my dreamland magic world where all mechannics are up for grabs on one off cards for every standard legal set, this is reprinted every time prismatic vista or evolving wilds isn't in a set.

Also small side note: at time of release, prismatic vista is 15 fucking dollars. FIFTEEN. This card is literally a power level compromise at the best of times in modern, and it's not actually that great. I've played with it. Even in cubes it's middling at best. Please, dear god add it to your cubes, it's a solid card to have in an enviornment, but it's always about the 3rd best thing you could be playing in it's spot, and it's only a biiiiiiiiiiiiiit better than a basic.
Can you believe people are predicting it's going to rise in price? Fuck me...
 
Top