I've been drafting the cube a bit and trying to force black decks to get an idea of what the colour needs and it has proven a bit difficult. The reason is that many of the possible decks rely on colours that are still far from finished and, hence, archetypes don't come out too well. For example, I think this is one of the reasons the WB control decks don't come out so well. Some random thoughts:
This is far more useful than Tortured Existence ever was because you can run it in creature-light builds if those creatures have ETB effects or the like. I'm liking it a lot.
Artifacts will have a fairly large presence on the cube and, weirdly, Green will be one of its main colours. So I've been thinking about adding this card to signal a potential BG artifact theme. I don't like that it's pushed a 3/3 First Strike Deathtouch creature but it might be interesting.
The lack of 2-drops is fairly noticiable and one of the main problems with Black on my cube. I suppose cards like Nantuko Shade and Ravenous Rats have become obsolete and would fare rather poorly on the cube. I also hate that Brain Maggot is such a good fit (Disruption, versatile, Enchantment so it can come back with Replenish) but has such a disgusting-looking art.
I wish Dhund Operative got +1/+1 or even +0/+1. I thought Dire Fleet Poisoner was strong but then I read "target attacking Pirate" and saw it doesn't work as surprise removal. Knight of Malice is a 2 or 3 strenght first strike creature which helps both offensive and defensive decks but is otherwise not particularly synergetic. And that's all I can find for 1B on Scryfall.BB isn't much better, for the record. There are some cards that use energy counters that are interesting but I do not want to include the mechanic.
For the record, there are only 600 cards with a CC of 2 and B in their mana costs. Is it any surprise these drops are so hard to find? Either way, I don't think it matters much if all other colours do have valuable 2-drops and pick up enough black removal or other spells for 2CC.
By the way, I just discovered this card. How awful is it? Disrupting Scepter is one of my pet cards and I'm not sure making it 1 mana cheaper will make it work in an environment like this:
This is far more useful than Tortured Existence ever was because you can run it in creature-light builds if those creatures have ETB effects or the like. I'm liking it a lot.
Artifacts will have a fairly large presence on the cube and, weirdly, Green will be one of its main colours. So I've been thinking about adding this card to signal a potential BG artifact theme. I don't like that it's pushed a 3/3 First Strike Deathtouch creature but it might be interesting.
The lack of 2-drops is fairly noticiable and one of the main problems with Black on my cube. I suppose cards like Nantuko Shade and Ravenous Rats have become obsolete and would fare rather poorly on the cube. I also hate that Brain Maggot is such a good fit (Disruption, versatile, Enchantment so it can come back with Replenish) but has such a disgusting-looking art.
I wish Dhund Operative got +1/+1 or even +0/+1. I thought Dire Fleet Poisoner was strong but then I read "target attacking Pirate" and saw it doesn't work as surprise removal. Knight of Malice is a 2 or 3 strenght first strike creature which helps both offensive and defensive decks but is otherwise not particularly synergetic. And that's all I can find for 1B on Scryfall.BB isn't much better, for the record. There are some cards that use energy counters that are interesting but I do not want to include the mechanic.
For the record, there are only 600 cards with a CC of 2 and B in their mana costs. Is it any surprise these drops are so hard to find? Either way, I don't think it matters much if all other colours do have valuable 2-drops and pick up enough black removal or other spells for 2CC.
By the way, I just discovered this card. How awful is it? Disrupting Scepter is one of my pet cards and I'm not sure making it 1 mana cheaper will make it work in an environment like this: